After reading Manuel Munoz's essay, "Leave your name at the Border" in Convergences, I'm left to ponder a few thoughts. Munoz talks about identity among Mexicans, when it comes to pronunciation of their names, or even the Anglicization of their names. He uses the example of family members distancing themselves from traditional Mexican names to more Americanized names like Brandon or Kaitlyn.
Why are people replacing their culture with appearance? Munoz states that the perception of Mexicans being lower class illegal immigrants, basically forces them to. For example, his step father changed his name from Antonio to Tony; Not because he wanted to , but because he didn't want to be passed over for work. In a day and age of supposed equal opportunities, it is sad to see such stereotypes still exist. When someone has to actually change their name, and abandon their culture in order to be accepted in our society, what does that say about us?
One thing that surprised me in the article was when Munoz pointed out in a few different occasions when he was shocked to hear a name pronounced correctly, or to see someone still using a traditional Mexican name. They have become so accustomed to people not respecting their culture, or attempting to pronounce their names correctly, that it actually shocks and confused them when someone does.
Another thing I found fascinating was the gate agent, a Mexican woman, at the airport. She called a Mexican man overhead, and he had a traditional Mexican name. He wondered if she would speak to him in Spanish or would she speak loudly to him as if he were deaf, assuming he didn't know English due to his Mexican name he didn't change. Basically, he was wondering since she has a good job and is using make-up to lighten her skin color, if she totally abandoned her heritage. It's sad to think a person has to separate themselves from their background in order to feel accepted by their own society.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Very smart reflection. I agree that its sad that in our country people feel that they can't be proud of their heritage and still be successful. America is supposed to be a place where everyone is equal. You should not have to compromise your heritage to fit in to our society we should be accepting of everyone. Having to change your name is such an extreme thing to have to do. I think that your essay was a bit repetitive but overall it was great, your raised a lot of good points.
ReplyDeleteGreat response, I'm definitely going to take a look at that article.
ReplyDeleteI like how you state the author's opinion and your own and finishes the response with your own experience on the issue, but maybe the last two paragraphs could be merged together.
As a Latino I agree that it's hard to maintain a cultural identity in America without feeling the pressure to become "Americanized." It's even harder because after we move to America, we also have to feel the scrutiny of Latinos back home that feel you have turned on your culture just because you are trying to adapt to this country.
Anyway, great reading response, very interesting topic.